Graphic As A Star

Rate It! Avg: 3.5 (25 ratings)
Graphic As A Star album cover
Album Information

Total Tracks: 27   Total Length: 44:30

Write a Review 7 Member Reviews

Please register before you review a release. Register

user avatar

TwoHeaded / Double Standard

agucate

TwoHeadedBoy's review is really sexist, if you ask me (why don't male vocalists ever get accused of sounding like each other?). Also, purity is a myth. I think it's really interesting how Foster uses Dickinson's poems here. Foster's music is great, captivating, and engrossing -- it must be really threatening to TwoHeadedBoy's f'ed-up world-order.

user avatar

Expressive Voices

OpeningtheField

Josephine Foster is one of those too rare singers who actually uses her voice as an instrument. Not about (or *just* about) storytelling, but as pure expressiveness. I love all her other work--including the album of children's songs--but had my doubts about this album until I saw her perform most of it recently in a very intimate "recital," the first of several in the States. It was one of the most amazing performances I've ever had the honor of seeing! I've only had similar experiences of feeling transported when seeing Jolie Holland, Antony, Liz Fraser/ Cocteau Twins, Diamanda Galas, and Jarboe (solo & w/Swans/World of Skin). Download this album, and listen to in a quiet, undistracted place. It cannot substitute for seeing Foster herself: but it comes close enough...

user avatar

This is just plain weird

JBB

Josephine Foster began the wyrd folk vocal thing about the same time as Joanna Newson. However she has been more prolific and adventurous than Newson - and sometimes not as sucessful. In this case it just doesn’t work. The songs are awkward, boring and a surrealistically contrived as if emitted from a 1920’s gramophone. I loved her 2005 masterpiece Hazel Eyes, I Will Lead You. Her neo-psychedelic rock with the Supposed had many great moments, but this, like her strange German classical covers album leaves me flat. I usually like weird, but this is just plain weird.

user avatar

This lady is American Idol Material

EMUSIC-022EF136

She would be revered in the category of the ten worst. I've heard hound dogs make better music. Well, it may have been Emily's hound.

user avatar

TwoHeadedBoy...

thelittlefield

...nailed it. Took the words right out of my mouth.

user avatar

Is this satire? (Part 2 of 2)

TwoHeadedBoy

Josephine Foster seems to be under the impression that the indie community will latch on to anyone who sounds like Joanna Newsom at a peace festival during an earthquake. She has done NO work on this record. The songs are predominantly lyric-focused, yet the lyrics are not hers. Worse-- the lyrics are Dickinson's, who intentionally stifled the publishing of her writing so that it wouldn't be dismantled and butchered (exhibit A: this record). Not to mention the fact that her inane, mindless method of ripping-off the poems leads her to disregard Dickinson's line-breaks and dashes, thereby devaluing the last shred of dignity the words alone may have had. Josephine Foster-- stop making lazy music. It is criminally pathetic. Everyone who's thinkin of buying this album-- get the Karaoke version of the Gilligan's Island theme and sing Dickinson poems to that! They fit far better, and the instrumentation/song- - writing is more complex, original, and entertaining.

user avatar

Josephine Sings Emily

nhpeacenik

This seems to be an entire album of Emily Dickinson poems set to music. They are mostly lesser-known poems with deep resonances, and each track I have heard to far is an absolute gem as sung and arranged (voice, guitar, harmonica, bird-song) by Josephine Foster. The musical settings make the poems much more interesting to me than they ever were on a flat page, and I find myself now re-reading and puzzling over the words.

Recommended Albums

They Say All Music Guide

When Josephine Foster released A Wolf in SheepÂ’s Clothing in 2006, she provocatively set the lieder of composers like Schumman, Brahms, and Schubert in a unique setting. She sang them in German and played acoustic guitar, piano, and harmonica with improvising electric guitarist Brian Goodman accompanying her for a cotemporary feel. Though her music exists in a unique space, she echos risk-taking classic folk performers such as Shirley Collins. On Graphic as a Star — her debut album for Fire Records — she has written music to the poems of Emily Dickinson, and the fit is seamless. She conceived the 26-song cycle while living in a remote region of Spain and had brought very few books with her. DickinsonÂ’s poems provided comfort. In her liner notes she claims these songs came together in a matter of weeks. Musically, this is more sparse than anything sheÂ’s ever recorded — accompanying herself only on an acoustic guitar, sometimes with a primitive-sounding harmonica added. She also she sings a cappella (“Wild Nights – Wild Nights!”) or with only the sounds of chirping birds in the background (“What Shall I Do – It Whimpers So -”). While all of FosterÂ’s work is provocative, this proves the warmest, loveliest, and most beautifully articulated recording in her catalog. These poems (which were also written in solitude; Dickinson was a self-imposed shut-in) easily lend themselves to FosterÂ’s song forms, due to the poetÂ’s keen sense of time, rhythm, and space. Dickinson’s writing is often wonderfully elliptical in image and meaning; Foster underscores this here: there are no choruses. These songs are small but evoke the vast emptiness surrounding them. They donÂ’t feel melancholy, even when they are, such as in “My Life Had Stood – A Loaded Gun -.“ Instead they are evocative of an America at once imagined and longed for — and this sense of homesickness is evident in the reedy beauty of FosterÂ’s voice — which is more controlled and tempered here than ever before; she seems to have found the exact pitch and timbre sheÂ’s sought since the beginning. While the entire cycle is gorgeous and the tunes nearly inseparable from one another, a couple of tracks lend themselves to singling out: the lilting early American folk melody in “Tho’ My Destiny Be Fustian -“ and the languid, bluesy stroll of “I Could bring You Jewels – Had I a Mind To -.” Graphic as a Star is exquisite. – Thom Jurek

more »